New post
Avatar
1

I understand why Makemusic created the Score Manager. And perhaps it makes life easier for novice users. But for experienced users it is (still) a major regression after five years and counting.

It basically replaced Staff Styles for instrument changes. But let us count the ways Staff Styles remain superior:

1) You can see Staff Styles as you work. Right now the only way to discover the exact bar of an instrument change is to open the Score Manager and fish it out. Oof.

2) You can easily apply Staff Styles and (equally important) unapply them in specified bars. As far as I can tell, the only way right now to change the bars of a doubling instrument is to delete it completely and reapply it. Change Instrument does literally nothing when I select a portion of a doubling instrument and try to revert it to the main instrument. No message, no Undo entry, nothing. Really? (I would love to be told I missed something.)

3) A Staff Style can easily be applied to a single measure or even a partial measure. Change Instrument won't do it, even for a full bar. Not sure about other ways.

4) It seems like you can only have one instrument per Garritan instrument. Consider this example. I would like to have someone double on a large semi-pitched bell and on tubular bells. It turns out the best playback option in Finale for the large semi-pitched bell is also the Garritan tubular bells. I have not been able to figure out a simple way to prevent my instrument changes from always being one name (with 1-line staff) or the other name with 5-line staff. Maybe it's possible with a lot of fiddling in Score Manager. I haven't pursued it. Staff Styles to override Score Manager's stubbornness are simply far easier in this situation.

5) Applying Change Instrument to a few bars apparently removes all midmeasure clef changes throughout the entire staff.

I also have a huge related issue with Human Playback. It appears not to recognize, for example, a violin unless the base instrument name starts with the word "Violin". I have had to prepend the word "Violin" in hidden text to "I" and "II" in orchestral scores to get, e.g., pizz and arco playback. Recently I discovered that Human Playback does not recognize a violin as a doubling instrument. That is, the underlying instrument is something else, and where I used "Change Instrument" to specify violin, none of the pizz, arco stuff happens. Human playback should be based on the playback sound and not the instrument name.

 

2 comments

Date Votes

Official comment

Avatar

Hi Robert:

 

Thank you for posting your request and providing specific situations that need to be addressed. I agree the Score Manager needs to be further improved to address workflow bottlenecks and UX confusion.  Your comments have been added to FIN-4887, the story in our backlog on the topic.

 

Cheers,
Michael Johnson
VP, Professional Notation
MakeMusic

Comment actions Permalink
Avatar
0

Workarounds that seem like they might help with some of your issues:

1) If you're using the Aria player, you can assign multiple instruments to the same Midi channel. It's not hard once you find it and would allow you to stack more than one percussion instrument on the same channel; hence the same Finale instrument

2) I have an enhancement request in on a similar topic, but my current workaround for getting multiple articulations on the same staff system is to expand the instrument in the Score Manager and assign different "instruments" (articulations of the same instrument) to different layers. It's far from perfect, but I'm a guitarist and am well-versed in dealing with layers. So this workaround just seemed to come naturally to me...

Comment actions Permalink

Please sign in to leave a comment.