New post
Avatar
1

Few proposals for improvement of Finale:

- page layout: not only system margins adjustment for page 1 - 6, but also 1 - 6, 9 ,13;
- lyrics: there is vertically a bit of space between the dotted line and the lyrics that appears: would be better if this would be 0;
- double click on double barline etc. to add it, without having to press the OK-button;
- when I hide time signatures in bar 2 and 4 because each bar has a different time signature - which I don't want to show - then it should also be
hidden when I copy and insert those bars elsewhere in my humble opinion. This is not the case now;
- adjusting syllables with arrow keys changes music spacing now. Would be better if this would not happen;
- when I'm using the measure spacing handles to move the first beat to the right, then this spacing is removed when I apply note spacing, which is a routine for me, just as using update layout. Would be better if these would me separate things. If I remember correctly, in the earliest versions of finale (like 3.1 etc) this was not a problem.

- Opening a new file should not ask for saving if I didn't edit anything, which in some versions of Finale was I believe also a default setting.

- Sometimes when I want to add a time signature, finale doesn't let me choose one, but adds one, although I can use the right mouse knob and the menu available there. So I have to start up finale again, to make it work again. I guess this is a bug.

4 comments

Date Votes
Avatar
0

Are you using Windows Finale ? - v27 ?

 

 

… - page layout: not only system margins adjustment for page 1 - 6, but also 1 - 6, 9 ,13; …

 

Non-contiguous selection has been requested for years.

Perhaps some day.

 

 

… - lyrics: there is vertically a bit of space between the dotted line and the lyrics that appears: would be better if this would be 0; …

 

I am afraid I do not understand.

Do you mean horizontally (rather than vertically) ?

Do you mean dashed line (rather than dotted line) ? - perhaps hyphens ? - or word extensions ?

 

 

… - double click on double barline etc. to add it, without having to press the OK-button; …

 

Good idea, and similar to how Finale works in other dialog boxes, such as e. g. Expression Selection.

 

 

… - when I hide time signatures in bar 2 and 4 because each bar has a different time signature - which I don't want to show - then it should also be hidden when I copy and insert those bars elsewhere in my humble opinion. This is not the case now; …

 

You are using a staff style to hide time signatures - right ?

Did you select the staff style option “Copyable” ?

 

 

… - adjusting syllables with arrow keys changes music spacing now. Would be better if this would not happen; …

 

Perhaps you have {Automatic Music Spacing} toggled on ?

Before doing layout work I would toggle {Automatic Music Spacing} off.

 

 

… - when I'm using the measure spacing handles to move the first beat to the right, then this spacing is removed when I apply note spacing, which is a routine for me, just as using update layout. Would be better if these would me separate things. If I remember correctly, in the earliest versions of finale (like 3.1 etc) this was not a problem …

 

Why are you not adding Extra Space at the Beginning of the measure (this is done in the Measure Attributes) ?

 

 

… - Sometimes when I want to add a time signature, finale doesn't let me choose one, but adds one, although I can use the right mouse knob and the menu available there. So I have to start up finale again, to make it work again. I guess this is a bug …

 

Sounds like the “stuck key syndrome”.

What is the metatool trigger key for the (unwanted) time signature Finale adds ?

Possibly that very key is stuck (electronically or physically).

Have you tried a re-boot ?

Comment actions Permalink
Avatar
0

Are you using Windows Finale ? - v27 ?

Yes

lyrics: there is vertically a bit of space between the dotted line:

Good question, my description was not clear. It's when lyrics have been entered and one wants to adjust height with the arrows: they show a dotted line.

Did you select the staff style option “Copyable” ?

It doesn't ssem to make a difference.

Why are you not adding Extra Space at the Beginning of the measure (this is done in the Measure Attributes) ?

This would apply to all measures. Handle bars are for manual adjustment of particular bars.

What is the metatool trigger key for the (unwanted) time signature Finale adds ?

I actually didn't know there are metatool triggers for time signatures ;) thanks for the tip. It might be

a bug, because I don't use metatool triggers/ shortcuts for entering time signatures. Restarting helps,

but that's not what we want ;)

Thanks for your comment/feedback ;)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Comment actions Permalink
Avatar
0

… It's when lyrics have been entered and one wants to adjust height with the arrows: they show a dotted line …

 

Unfortunately I am unable to reproduce this in my own copy of Mac Finale v27.3.0.160.

For me, there is not vertically any space between the dotted line and the lyrics.

 

 

… Did you select the staff style option “Copyable” ?

It doesn't seem to make a difference …

 

For me it makes a difference:

When the option {Copyable} is selected, the staff style is copied with the measures.

 

 

… Why are you not adding Extra Space at the Beginning of the measure (this is done in the Measure Attributes) ?

This would apply to all measures …

 

For me, the Extra Space at the Beginning only applies to the selected measure(s).

Comment actions Permalink
Avatar
0

Thanks. I will have a look at the last thing you mentioned. The first two points might be a difference between mac and windows, I'm not sure.

Comment actions Permalink

Please sign in to leave a comment.