New post
Avatar
0

Finale 25.5.0.290

Aria Player v1.872, Engine x64 v1.960

Windows 10 (Three machines: Studio, Office and Laptop; lowest spec is Ryzen 5 8GB, 512 GB SSD, highest is Core i7, 32GB, 1TB SSD+4TB HD)

 

Every playback mode I have tried has issues:

- Using VST with Garritan/CoMB 2 and/or Aria usually results in voices dropping out and expressions not rendering.

- Using MIDI is just generally awful, I won't bore you with details

 

So I have settled on:

- VST -> SmartMusic SoftSynth.

- Audio driver is DirectSound (and/or ASIO on my Studio machine) Also, changing buffer size does not help.

- Human playback is OFF (which is a problem, I would prefer it to be ON, but that creates other problems)

 

In that mode, when I load a concert band arrangement (22 staves, 8 of which have two layers) and press play, the first time it plays sounds fine. After that, there is an annoying "helicopter" effect until I reboot the PC. More specifically, there is a "thwop thwop thwop thwop" sound that corresponds to 16th notes at the current tempo, which blurs into a dull roar with that many channels.

 

Merely shutting down Finale does NOT help, nor does clearing MIDI data, sending all notes off, or anything of that sort I have tried. This happens on ALL THREE machines. 

 

This reproduces on all my other projects as well, but while on small ensembles (until recently, almost all my projects were quartets or quintets) it's only a minor nuisance and I can live with it, (and have been since I got Finale 25,) with a full band score it's unusable. Muting all the tracks but a few at a time lets me get SOME work done, but it's really driving me nuts.

Any suggestions on how to get usable playback would be deeply appreciated. Thanks.

 

 

3 comments

Date Votes
Avatar
0

Bump.

Not just me:

https://makemusic.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/community/posts/360002012774-Low-pitch-noise-in-Playback

https://makemusic.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/community/posts/218045247-Low-Noise-in-Human-Playback

https://forum.makemusic.com/default.aspx?f=6&m=482424&_ga=2.220738076.585453488.1580056334-1204079300.1563810357

That last one sort of helped  - a little. There were some weird invisible expressions in the score set to Dump KS=0. When I removed them, it will playback without noise, but ONLY if I start from bar 1. Start in bar 2 or later, and it's back. Very frustrating when working on the ending of a 6+ minute piece.

 

Comment actions Permalink
Avatar
0

What is your audio buffer set to? It might be too small.

 

Comment actions Permalink
Avatar
0

No, this is a different noise than buffer crackle. (I get that using ASIO, which is one reason I use DirectSound.)

However, mine is at 1024. 512 and 2048 sound exactly the same. If I set it up to 4096, I get a different problem: periodic high-pitched pulses like someone attacking a synth with an ice pick.

 

 

Comment actions Permalink

Please sign in to leave a comment.