Operating System: Mac > 10.11 (El Capitan)

Software: version 25

Hi, and thank you for your help.

The other day, I was on a Zoom call and was presenting a piece I had written in Finale. When it was time to share the playback, I went through the MIDI/Audio drop-down, to Device Setup, to Audio Setup, and selected my output to Zoom Audio Device. I shared my piece and that was that. After I logged off, I went back to my Finale app and changed my settings back to the Built-In Audio Output. However, every time I press play, there is no playback. Instead, after I press pause, sometimes there will be some choppy playback that is fragmented and broken; other times, nothing. I've looked online, but it seems like this is kind of a specific problem as no one has posted on this. I've tried resetting my computer, resetting my audio setups, etc... but nothing seems to work. Does anyone know what may be the problem and how I can fix it?