New post
Avatar
2

This is a problem Finale users have to work around since the beginning. Let's say you make a measure or a multi-measure rest wider (by dragging its handle or in the measure attributes dialog/measure width setting. When automatic music spacing is turned on in the edit preferences, Finale will automatically erase all manually adjusted measure widths. That's just terrible for so many reasons. 
1. You send your Finale file to someone who opens it with automatic music spacing turned on and who then performs the music spacing function for what ever reason. All the measure width adjustments you made will be gone.

2. The only workaround to preserve user made measure width changes is by always have automatic music spacing turned off. This is very inconvenient because you will have to always make sure you only select the music you need to space and then manually force spacing.

3. It is one more thing you constantly have to do to make the music look right.

What makemusic could do to get rid of the problem is simply adding a new music spacing preference that can be checked reading as follows:

INCORPORATE (or keep) MANUAL MEASURE WIDTH ADJUSTMENTS WHEN RE-SPACING THE MUSIC

I reported this issue to the finale support team, but as everyone knows, they will only move on this when lots of us complain about this problem. So all you professional music engravers using Finale, please write them about this problem!

 

7 comments

Date Votes
Avatar
0

When the measure widths automatically get changed, the culprit could be Automatic Music Spacing.

 

But the culprit could also be a document setting:

Document Options > Multimeasure Rests > Update Automatically

When - from Scroll View - notes are added to a multimeasure rest, the setting {Update Automatically} breaks the multimeasure rest, and adjusts the layout.

The setting affects the widths of all measures, not just the widths of multimeasure rests.

You should de-select {Update Automatically} when you have finished entering music, and begin working on the layout.

 

But you probably already knew that.

Comment actions Permalink
Avatar
1

Thanks, and I agree with what you wrote, but I am not sure you understand my main problem. I don't care about creating multi measure rests. It is about manual measure width adjustments of any measure, including the width of multi measure rests. And the only way to keep them as of now is by never to space the music again. 

Yes, ideally, you do all the layout tweaking after all the music has been inputted. But how often do we make changes, add measures, change rhythms of just a few bars after a rehearsal for example. That's when it gets tricky. It would all be super easy if Final would allow us to lock our layout and unlock it for selected measures only. And of course it would really help to have my feature request for incorporating manual measure width adjustments when spacing music taken care of.

Cheers!

Comment actions Permalink
Avatar
1

I have been asking for a "leave it alone, dammit" setting for a long time.

Comment actions Permalink
Avatar
0

Another, similar request:

Make the setting {Automatic Music Spacing} a document setting, rather than a program setting.

Comment actions Permalink
Avatar
0

Maybe I'm misunderstanding the problem. But all of my multimeasure rests which get respaced manually keep any adjustments I make, they never change on their own.

 

I make my spacing decisions at the end of the engraving process with, locking systems, turning off automatic music spacing and turning off multi-measure rests, update automatically. With these settings intact all multi-rests follow my spacing decisions.

Comment actions Permalink
Avatar
0

Of course it keeps your manual measure width changes when you turn off automatic music spacing and you don’t space it manually. But we shouldn’t have to worry about that in the first place. If our measure width changes would be locked (which should be the default setting in my opinion), and any manual spacing gets incorporated when spacing the music, we would never have to worry about spacing the music after we made changes. You see what I mean?

Comment actions Permalink
Avatar
0

In a related issue -- any expression (particularly tempo markings and other expressions which can include lengthy text) should have a setting available to force measures to be wide enough to accommodate them without having the expression extend into the next measure(s).

 

Comment actions Permalink

Please sign in to leave a comment.