Just a comment on that - wish I could connect my comment to the relevant post. The one in question shows a score with enormous time signatures at the beginning with 2 or 3 space ed vertically under it, then a few more as the time signature changes - all enormous. Who benefits from these big time signatures? I'm guessing the person conducting the piece. Since forever, conductors have been marking their scores as they like. Ernest Ansermet used red and blue pencils for various markings. We in the l'Orch. de la Suisse Romande were forbidden to erase or alter them. Anyway, my question as a musician, and Finale user, and arranger, why do you like to use these enormous time signatures? Because you like the way they look? Well, that's subjective, isn't it. Plus, a big time signature uses valuable space on the score and pushes all the notes to the right to make room for the enormous time signature. That doesn't look good to me. A measure with 4 quarter notes has a certain size. Put an enormous (yes, I like writing that word) time signature at the beginning of the bar and now that 4/4 measure is stretched to the size of a 6/4 or 7/4 bar. Not good; not logical. Final comment/question - are the enormous time signatures also in the individual parts? I'm guessing they are probably not. Apparently, Dorico doesn't like the enormous time signatures either. I'm no fan of Dorico, btw, I'm sticking to Finale and not using enormous time signatures.
Dennis Anthony Guterwicz
Finale - 27.3.0.160
OS 14.7.4











9 comments
Date Votes